you can see everything: elizabeth holmes still has a story to sell
I figured we'd pretty much heard the last of Elizabeth Holmes. After all, how many times can you tell the story of a woman who convinced a bunch of very smart people that she'd invented a miracle blood-testing machine when, in fact, she hadn't? Apparently, at least one more time. You Can See Everything, the new documentary from Nathan Fielder and Lance Oppenheim, takes us inside Holmes's home during the final weeks before she goes to prison. And I have to say, it's a pretty strange experience. Not because we learn some shocking new secret about Theranos, but because we get to spend nearly three hours watching Holmes try to convince us that she's not the person we think she is. Whether she succeeds is another matter entirely.
The filmmakers show up 34 days before Holmes is supposed to report to prison. She's living with her partner, Billy Evans, and their two young children, and she's clearly hoping this documentary will give people a different impression of her. And sometimes it does. She comes across as surprisingly ordinary. She talks about her kids, her relationship, and how unfairly she thinks she's been treated. But then Fielder starts asking questions, and things get interesting. He's very good at making people uncomfortable without seeming to do much of anything. He just asks a question, waits for an answer, and then asks another one. Holmes, meanwhile, has this remarkable ability to talk at length without ever quite answering what she's been asked. You find yourself leaning forward, thinking, "Come on, just answer the question!" But she rarely does.
What's unusual about this documentary is that the filmmakers keep reminding us that they're part of the story, too. They're not just sitting there recording whatever happens. They're making choices, setting things up, and occasionally messing with our expectations. There are reenactments, some odd twists, and moments when you're not entirely sure what you're supposed to believe. I liked a lot of that, although there were times when I wished they'd knock it off and get back to Holmes. Fielder can be very funny, but he can also get a little carried away with his own cleverness. Still, I found myself going along with it, partly because I genuinely wanted to see where the whole thing was headed.
The strangest part, for me, was how sympathetic Holmes could seem at times. Here's a woman who's about to leave her two little kids and go to prison. That's sad, no matter how you feel about her. And there are moments when she seems genuinely frightened and vulnerable. But then you remember why she's going to prison in the first place. She built a company on claims that weren't true, took enormous amounts of money from investors, and persuaded people to trust medical technology that didn't work the way she said it did. Those things don't disappear just because she's a loving mother or because she seems nice over breakfast. And I think that's one of the things the documentary gets right. People who do dishonest things aren't necessarily dishonest every minute of the day. They can be funny, affectionate, charming, and completely convincing. n fact, being convincing was pretty much Holmes's greatest talent.
I also kept coming back to the whole Elizabeth Holmes persona. Remember the black turtlenecks? The deep voice? The intense stare? She was obviously trying to be Steve Jobs, or at least some version of Steve Jobs she'd invented for herself. And it worked. People wanted to believe in her. They wanted the story of the brilliant young woman who was going to change medicine forever. The actual blood-testing machine almost became beside the point. Watching this film, I started wondering whether Holmes ever really separated the person she was from the person she was pretending to be. Maybe she'd been playing the role for so long that she'd convinced herself. I don't know. And after nearly three hours, I'm not sure the filmmakers know either.
Is You Can See Everything too long? Oh, absolutely. There are probably 30 or 40 minutes that could have gone without anyone missing much. And some of the filmmaking tricks are more interesting in theory than they are to sit through. But I was never sorry I watched it. Holmes is still a fascinating character, and there's something almost hypnotic about watching someone try so hard to control how other people see her. What I came away thinking about, though, wasn't really Theranos or even Holmes herself. It was how easily we can be persuaded to believe something simply because somebody tells us a good story. Holmes was awfully good at that. And the funny thing is, even knowing everything we know about her, I occasionally caught myself wanting to believe her again.

Comments