when a monologue earns its place
There is a moment in almost every new play workshop when an actor takes a breath, steps forward, and begins speaking. And speaking. And speaking. Somewhere around the third minute, the playwright leans forward, the director studies the floor, and the other actors develop an intense interest in their shoes. The monologue may be beautifully written. It may contain the most poetic language in the script. It may even earn applause. But none of that answers the essential question: Why does this character need to speak for so long, and why must we hear it now? A monologue doesn't earn its place because the writing is impressive. It earns its place because the play cannot move forward without it.
The first test of a monologue is necessity. What does the character want, and why is speaking the only way to get it? In Hamlet, the famous "To be or not to be" soliloquy isn't simply Shakespeare showing off his command of language. It dramatizes a mind struggling with the unbearable consequences of living and dying. In A Few Good Men, Colonel Jessup's courtroom explosion isn't an opportunity for Jack Nicholson to chew the scenery. It's the moment his arrogance overwhelms his self-control and produces the confession that destroys him. Both speeches are actions, not interruptions. The characters aren't merely telling us what they think. They're doing something dangerous by speaking. A good monologue is not a speech about the conflict. It is the conflict.
Too often, playwrights use monologues as convenient delivery systems for backstory. A character recounts a traumatic childhood, a failed marriage, or a long-buried secret, and the playwright assumes that revelation automatically equals drama. It doesn't. Information is not action, and confession is not necessarily transformation. Consider Tom's opening narration in The Glass Menagerie. Tennessee Williams isn't simply providing background about the Wingfield family; Tom is attempting to control a memory that continues to haunt him. His narration establishes the play's central tension between escape and responsibility. Or consider the extended speeches in August Wilson's Fences, where Troy Maxson's stories about baseball, death, and his own past are acts of self-mythologizing. He's constructing a version of himself that his family is expected to accept. The stories reveal him, but they also expose the distance between the man he claims to be and the man standing before us. That's what makes them theatrical.
Another test is whether the monologue changes the temperature of the room. Before the speech, something must be at stake. Afterward, something must be different. A relationship may fracture. A lie may become impossible to sustain. A character may discover something about himself that he would rather not know. Even silence can become an active force when another character refuses to respond. The mistake is assuming that length creates importance. It doesn't. A ninety-second monologue can devastate an audience, while a ten-minute speech can drain the life from a scene. During rehearsal, try removing the monologue entirely. If the scene still works, if the characters continue behaving exactly as before, and if the audience loses nothing essential beyond a few interesting facts, the speech probably hasn't earned its place. The solution isn't always cutting it. Sometimes the playwright must give the speaker a more urgent objective, a more resistant listener, or a greater price to pay for telling the truth.
Ultimately, a monologue earns its place when the audience stops noticing that it's a monologue. We are no longer counting lines or admiring metaphors. We are watching someone fight for something, perhaps without fully understanding what that something is. The best monologues contain contradictions, evasions, discoveries, and moments when language fails the speaker. They don't merely explain a character; they expose the character's struggle to explain himself. And they leave the play altered in ways that cannot be undone. Playwrights should be ruthless with speeches they love, especially the ones that sound magnificent at a reading. Beautiful writing is a pleasure, but dramatic necessity is the standard. The question isn't whether a monologue deserves to be heard. It's whether the character can afford not to say it.

Comments