top of page

what does your character want — and why can’t they say it?

Writer: Michael David
Michael David
Oct 27
3 min read

A character comes into the kitchen and complains about the dishes. The dishes may actually be dirty. But after three minutes of argument, we begin to suspect that washing them will not solve the problem. Somebody wants to be appreciated. Somebody wants proof that the other person intends to stay. Somebody has spent 20 years cleaning up after a marriage and would like, just once, to hear an acknowledgment. The dishes give them something they can point to. Their actual grievance is harder to put on the table.


“What does your character want?” is useful advice, though the first answer is often too general to write a scene. Love. Respect. Freedom. Those are substantial desires, but an actor needs something to pursue in the room. Get him to put down his suitcase. Make her introduce me as her partner. Persuade my father to attend the opening. A desire becomes playable when another person can grant it, refuse it, or make the character pay for it. Now the conversation has somewhere to go, even if neither person mentions what is really happening.


The next question is what speaking plainly would cost. If a woman says, “I want you to stay,” she gives the person at the door the power to reject her. If a father says, “I need you to admire me,” he exposes how much he depends on the child he keeps correcting. Silence protects something: pride, authority, a relationship, a version of oneself. That protection has to matter. Otherwise, the audience starts wondering why these people don’t simply have a sensible conversation and let everyone go home.


Often, a character can’t say what they want because they don’t quite know it themselves. The father sincerely believes he is offering helpful criticism. The woman at the door thinks she is asking about tomorrow’s schedule. People can recognize an immediate irritation while remaining remarkably inventive about its source. A playwright can let the audience see the pattern before the character does: every suggestion becomes a correction, every practical question delays the departure. The behavior tells us what the dialogue keeps failing to acknowledge.


That gap is where tactics become interesting. A character offers a drink, makes a joke, finds fault, produces a gift, or suddenly develops an urgent concern about the weather. Each move is an attempt to get something without making the naked request. When one fails, they try another. The offer becomes a complaint; the complaint becomes a threat. This gives a scene movement. Two people may spend 10 pages discussing whether someone should drive home, but the struggle changes each time one of them finds a new way to keep the other in the room.


There is also the character who knows exactly what they want and understands that honesty would ruin their chances. “I’m worried about you” may be an effective way to make an adult daughter doubt her own judgment. “Think of the company” may persuade an employee to sacrifice something the boss would never sacrifice himself. These lines become revealing when we watch what happens after the listener refuses. Does the concern survive disagreement? Does the appeal to loyalty include any reciprocal obligation? A character’s response to resistance can expose more than a confession would.


Eventually, the playwright has to decide whether the unsaid thing will be spoken. There is no automatic virtue in a climactic declaration. Sometimes “Please stay” is devastating because we have watched a proud person exhaust every other means of asking. Sometimes it is more powerful to watch that person straighten a coat collar, mention the rain, and allow the door to close. Either ending can work if the choice carries a consequence. What matters is that the character has reached a point where concealment demands a sacrifice.


When a scene feels flat, I would look closely at what each character is trying to obtain and what prevents them from asking for it. The obstacle may be fear, ignorance, calculation, or the knowledge that the answer has already been given. Then I would look at the dialogue. Does it give the characters ways to pursue their desires, or merely allow them to describe their feelings? A person telling us they are lonely supplies information. A person inventing one last reason for a departing guest to sit down gives us a scene.

Recent Posts

See All
how to tell when a scene is dead

At a reading, a dead scene can get the biggest laugh of the night. Two sisters trade excellent insults while sorting their mother’s things. The actors know exactly how long to hold for each laugh.

 
 
 
when invention tells the truth better than fact

Theatre has always occupied a unique space between reality and imagination. While audiences know that the characters, settings, and events on stage are often fictional, these invented stories can rev

 
 
 
when a monologue earns its place

There is a moment in almost every new play workshop when an actor takes a breath, steps forward, and begins speaking. And speaking. And speaking. Somewhere around the third minute, the playwright l

 
 
 

Comments

Rated 0 out of 5 stars.
No ratings yet

Add a rating

Copyright © 2017-2026

bottom of page