how to watch a play

Watching a play as a theatre creator is different from watching it for pleasure. You’re not judging taste — you’re studying craft under pressure. Here’s how to do it without killing the magic.

1. Watch the problem, not the plot

Every play is trying to solve a dramatic problem.

Ask early:

• What does this play need to make true?

• What tension is it built to sustain?

• What would break if one character disappeared?

Don’t track events. Track necessity.

2. Identify the engine

Within the first 10–15 minutes, ask:

• What keeps this play moving when nothing happens?

• Is it desire, secrecy, time pressure, ritual, language?

If the engine stalls, note where — that’s a craft lesson, not a failure of taste.

3. Listen for the lie beneath the dialogue

Characters rarely say what the play is about.

Listen for:

• What they cannot say

• What language they repeat when they’re cornered

• What changes in how they speak when power shifts

When a line lands, ask: what made it inevitable?

4. Track energy, not acts

Forget structure labels. Watch energy curves:

• Where does the room tighten?

• Where does attention leak?

• Where do actors start working harder than the text?

These moments reveal where the writing is doing the work — and where production is compensating.

5. Notice what the audience forgives

This is crucial.

Ask:

• What flaws does the audience happily accept?

• What “shouldn’t work” but does?

• What technically works but leaves them cold?

Audiences forgive confusion, repetition, even mess — but not dishonesty.

6. Separate the play from the production

As a writer, you’re watching two things at once:

• What the script is asking

• How this production answers

If something fails, ask:

• Is this a writing problem, or a staging solution to a writing problem?

• Would a different production reveal something hidden?

This keeps you from lazy judgments.

7. Steal responsibly

Don’t steal lines. Steal moves:

• How a scene enters late and leaves early

• How a character withholds information

• How a simple action carries thematic weight

If you say “I’d never write like that,” ask why — that resistance often points to your own blind spot.

A quiet truth

Watching plays as a writer isn’t about becoming smarter. It’s about becoming more honest about what works — and what you secretly want permission to try.

Here's an opportunity to try these tips and techniques; watch the play True West, starring John Malkovich and Gary Sinise.