top of page

how to tell when a scene is dead

Writer: Michael David
Michael David
44 minutes ago
3 min read

At a reading, a dead scene can get the biggest laugh of the night. Two sisters trade excellent insults while sorting their mother’s things. The actors know exactly how long to hold for each laugh. Then one sister picks up a box, the other turns out the light, and we go on to the scene we were waiting for.


The laugh was real. So was the wait.


See what the next scene needs


Take the suspect scene out and read the pages on either side aloud. Does the next scene still make sense? More importantly, does it feel the same? If a daughter comes home in Act Two and her father says, “You kept the key,” the line may depend on an earlier scene in which we watched her put it in her pocket after promising to leave it on the table. Everybody in the audience can follow the line without that earlier scene. With it, we get to find out whether he saw her take it.


Try the cut with actors if you can. On the page, a scene can look expendable because it contains so little information. In the room, its absence may be the reason the next entrance feels abrupt or a laugh comes where you expected a silence.


Watch the second attempt


Go back to the sisters. Ruth wants May to sign the papers to sell the house. May wants Ruth to take one of the boxes home. In the first draft, Ruth asks for a signature three times. Each time, May makes a joke and goes on packing. The jokes get sharper, but Ruth can make her third request exactly the way she made her first. Nothing May has done has made Ruth reconsider how to get what she came for.


Give May something to do with the pen.

RUTH: Just sign where I marked it. May takes the pen. She writes RUTH on the box. RUTH: That one’s yours. MAY: Open it. Ruth opens the box. Inside are her own letters home, still in their envelopes. RUTH: She kept these? MAY: She kept yours.

Now try having Ruth ask for the signature again. She can do it, but the actor has a different line to play. A moment ago, Ruth could pass off the sale as something they both had to get through. Now May can hear the request as Ruth asking her to empty a house that held a different mother for each of them. And May, who could have packed the letters without a word, has to live with having shown them to her sister.


A repeated exchange can earn its place the same way. If someone says “Sign it” twice, look at what happened in between. Would the other actor hear the second request differently? If both requests give the actors the same work to do, try keeping the one that puts more at risk.


Leave the quiet scenes alone long enough to hear them


A woman sets two places for breakfast. She sits. After a while she gets up, puts one plate back in the cupboard, and leaves both cups on the table. That could be the whole scene. The audience has time to expect someone, then to watch her give up on that person coming for breakfast. The second cup lets us see how much hope she can still afford.


At a table read, somebody may race through that stage direction in four seconds. Put two plates and two cups in front of an actor and give the scene the time it asks for. Watch when the people in the room start looking at the empty chair. That’s part of the scene, too.


The next time a scene feels dead, resist the urge to give everybody better lines. Find the moment when an actor should have to change what they’re doing. If you can’t find it, run the play across the gap and see what you miss. You may discover that the thing you miss is one joke. Keep it handy. The sisters will have plenty to say once somebody opens the box.

Recent Posts

See All
when invention tells the truth better than fact

Theatre has always occupied a unique space between reality and imagination. While audiences know that the characters, settings, and events on stage are often fictional, these invented stories can rev

 
 
 
when a monologue earns its place

There is a moment in almost every new play workshop when an actor takes a breath, steps forward, and begins speaking. And speaking. And speaking. Somewhere around the third minute, the playwright l

 
 
 

Comments

Rated 0 out of 5 stars.
No ratings yet

Add a rating

Copyright © 2017-2026

bottom of page